Dear Gen X,
Hemingway Will Never Stop Kicking Your Ass
Folks my age, writers included, ultimately butt up against this conversation, and many protect themselves to the gills in an attempt to not get dusted by the topic through the age old defense mechanism—flat dismissal. Some folks amass a personal body of work so vast as to give them the right to call Hemingway a hack and not be reflexively refuted. Others compare their styles to his, but fall short, inasmuch as they don’t understand why their prose of existential high adventure doesn’t translate to an office setting or an Appalachian village during the Reconstruction. Ultimately, this discussion will remain molten hot for the course of our lifetimes, and picking a tack here is just as fun as backing it up.
The clever issue: the graveyard of writers-to-be is littered with good souls who can’t defeat the clever issue; either they’re convinced they can match or surpass writers like Ernest by simply having cleverness in their hearts as they compose, or they disassociate entirely by impugning all others as failures because they believe all efforts are nothing more than attempts at glibness and cleverness. No matter the angle of approach, this disease hampers so many artists to the point of paralysis, and it proves a sick desire—most artists want to prove to themselves, unequivocally, that they should no longer pursue art. Hating Hemingway is a round salve to this disease; a man can hang up his heart and pursuits and blame Ernest, claiming Papa E. is simply a clever man living at the height of human adventure and bragging about it. The key is to surpass cleverness in process and confidence to the point of terming it for the insult it is, for it’s the “cleverest” pejorative going. In my experience, the same people who hate puns are the same who introduce “clever” as the finest of dis-missives. Those who hate cleverness, even in themselves, are the ones who limit the range of expression to cleverness and believe, perversely, that there is no other tier of achievement.
As a big game hunter, Ernest had a taste for the exotic; he killed rare and dangerous animals, cleaned them, cooked them over fire and served them neatly, nakedly, and unapologetically. Anyone dining on his kill would come away from the experience a little unsettled, a little aroused, and—mostly—unable and unwilling to forget the experience. He was a Lincoln Brigade Brother, a bullfight aficionado and a sport fisherman who knew Spain, Italy, Africa and the Caribbean so intimately that they all would sue for palimony had he not regaled them in kind so well. He wrote a scene about a hyena so stupid to eat its own exposed entrails after becoming mortally wounded from a round of nickel shot. Boats, bulls, marlin, bullets, betrayal, soft women with aching breasts, I mean, c’mon! If one person had to set the table covering this material, whom else would you prefer?! I can guess, sure, um, Cather, Bronte, Twain, D.H. Lawrence, blah, bl…but, as far as SET and SETTING goes, I have even more recently appreciated how Ernest bridges the Masters for our generation. His knack, as far as I can appreciate it, is to acknowledge he is writing inside an exceptional environment, one that exceeds the experiences of most, and, with this in mind, he DEFERS to the magnitude of the moment and allows us to follow with standard eyes before an experience so rare and majestic, that his power of authorship and understatement makes us feel as though we had witnessed the moment with our very own senses. This is rote form for many, but with Ernest it was not about reading minds or issuing introspective judgment, it was about the visceral testimony, and no other writer comes within sniffing range when the subject matter is purely ocular and sensory. This may be why so many readers of Hemingway not only find the experience deeply personal, but they also adopt the man into their families as heritage and legacy.
My mother loves him more than I do, in fact, Ernest is the only connection we have and the only time I see my mother escaping herself is when she shares with me her wonderment of his stories. My mom doesn’t keep up with my own work, in fact it’s beyond a pained moment to broach the subject with anyone in my family, but she does have one copy of a book I wrote six years ago; she placed it on her living room library shelf, right next to her hardcover of A Farewell to Arms. And thank God for me I don’t write a thing like Ernest and will forever not have to bridge any remote comparisons, but, if my mother wants to put my book next to his on her shelf, that’s one thing I can keep with me, whether it was an accident or not that it’s there. -ped
Hemingway Will Never Stop Kicking Your Ass
Folks my age, writers included, ultimately butt up against this conversation, and many protect themselves to the gills in an attempt to not get dusted by the topic through the age old defense mechanism—flat dismissal. Some folks amass a personal body of work so vast as to give them the right to call Hemingway a hack and not be reflexively refuted. Others compare their styles to his, but fall short, inasmuch as they don’t understand why their prose of existential high adventure doesn’t translate to an office setting or an Appalachian village during the Reconstruction. Ultimately, this discussion will remain molten hot for the course of our lifetimes, and picking a tack here is just as fun as backing it up.
The clever issue: the graveyard of writers-to-be is littered with good souls who can’t defeat the clever issue; either they’re convinced they can match or surpass writers like Ernest by simply having cleverness in their hearts as they compose, or they disassociate entirely by impugning all others as failures because they believe all efforts are nothing more than attempts at glibness and cleverness. No matter the angle of approach, this disease hampers so many artists to the point of paralysis, and it proves a sick desire—most artists want to prove to themselves, unequivocally, that they should no longer pursue art. Hating Hemingway is a round salve to this disease; a man can hang up his heart and pursuits and blame Ernest, claiming Papa E. is simply a clever man living at the height of human adventure and bragging about it. The key is to surpass cleverness in process and confidence to the point of terming it for the insult it is, for it’s the “cleverest” pejorative going. In my experience, the same people who hate puns are the same who introduce “clever” as the finest of dis-missives. Those who hate cleverness, even in themselves, are the ones who limit the range of expression to cleverness and believe, perversely, that there is no other tier of achievement.
As a big game hunter, Ernest had a taste for the exotic; he killed rare and dangerous animals, cleaned them, cooked them over fire and served them neatly, nakedly, and unapologetically. Anyone dining on his kill would come away from the experience a little unsettled, a little aroused, and—mostly—unable and unwilling to forget the experience. He was a Lincoln Brigade Brother, a bullfight aficionado and a sport fisherman who knew Spain, Italy, Africa and the Caribbean so intimately that they all would sue for palimony had he not regaled them in kind so well. He wrote a scene about a hyena so stupid to eat its own exposed entrails after becoming mortally wounded from a round of nickel shot. Boats, bulls, marlin, bullets, betrayal, soft women with aching breasts, I mean, c’mon! If one person had to set the table covering this material, whom else would you prefer?! I can guess, sure, um, Cather, Bronte, Twain, D.H. Lawrence, blah, bl…but, as far as SET and SETTING goes, I have even more recently appreciated how Ernest bridges the Masters for our generation. His knack, as far as I can appreciate it, is to acknowledge he is writing inside an exceptional environment, one that exceeds the experiences of most, and, with this in mind, he DEFERS to the magnitude of the moment and allows us to follow with standard eyes before an experience so rare and majestic, that his power of authorship and understatement makes us feel as though we had witnessed the moment with our very own senses. This is rote form for many, but with Ernest it was not about reading minds or issuing introspective judgment, it was about the visceral testimony, and no other writer comes within sniffing range when the subject matter is purely ocular and sensory. This may be why so many readers of Hemingway not only find the experience deeply personal, but they also adopt the man into their families as heritage and legacy.
My mother loves him more than I do, in fact, Ernest is the only connection we have and the only time I see my mother escaping herself is when she shares with me her wonderment of his stories. My mom doesn’t keep up with my own work, in fact it’s beyond a pained moment to broach the subject with anyone in my family, but she does have one copy of a book I wrote six years ago; she placed it on her living room library shelf, right next to her hardcover of A Farewell to Arms. And thank God for me I don’t write a thing like Ernest and will forever not have to bridge any remote comparisons, but, if my mother wants to put my book next to his on her shelf, that’s one thing I can keep with me, whether it was an accident or not that it’s there. -ped
